| Arctic Fox | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Arctic Reindeer | Legendary | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Balloon Unicorn | Legendary | Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux) | |
| Bat Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2019 (Candy) | |
| Black Chow-Chow | Legendary | Golden Bone | |
| Black Springer Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | Easter 2022 | |
| Brown Springer Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | Easter 2022 | |
| Candyfloss Chick | Legendary | Easter 2024 (Robux) | |
| Chipmunk | Rare | September 2023 | |
| Chocolate Chip Bat Dragon | Legendary | Winter 2023 (Robux) | |
| Cow | Rare | Farm Egg | |
| Cow Calf | Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Cuddly Candle | Legendary | Sky Castle Refresh 2023 (Robux) | |
| Dodo | Legendary | Fossil Egg | |
| Dolphin | Uncommon | Ocean Egg | |
| English Sheepdog | Rare | Farm Theme 2023 | |
| Fairy Bat Dragon | Legendary | Winter 2024 (Robux) | |
| Fallow Deer | Legendary | Woodland Egg | |
| Flaming Fox | Ultra-Rare | Burnt Bites and Baked Alaska Baits | |
| Ghost | Common | Halloween 2023 | |
| Ghost Bunny | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 (Candy) | |
| Ghost Dog | Rare | Halloween 2023 | |
| Glyptodon | Uncommon | Fossil Egg | |
| Golden Penguin | Legendary | Golden Goldfish | |
| Hamster | Ultra-Rare | Golden Corn | |
| Happy Duckling | Rare | Duckling Box | |
| Husky | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Ice Cream Hermit Crab | Ultra-Rare | Hermit Crab Box | |
| Indian Flying Fox | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2024 | |
| Leopard Cat | Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Majestic Pony | Legendary | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Nutcracker Squirrel | Rare | Winter 2023 | |
| Orca | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Owl | Legendary | Farm Egg | |
| Owlbear | Legendary | Danger Egg | |
| Panda | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Peppermint Penguin | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2023 (Robux) | |
| Pig | Rare | Farm Egg | |
| Polar Bear | Rare | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Pomeranian | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Poodle | Uncommon | Regular Egg | |
| Pretty Pony | Ultra-Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Pumpkin Friend | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2024 | |
| Puptune | Ultra-Rare | Moon Egg | |
| Queen Bee | Legendary | Honey | |
| Red Squirrel | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Royal Corgi | Ultra-Rare | Royal Tea Party 2022 | |
| Royal Palace Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | Royal Tea Party 2022 (Robux) | |
| Shark Puppy | Legendary | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Snowball Pet | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 (Robux) | |
| St Bernard | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Strawberry Shortcake Bat Dragon | Legendary | Winter 2022 (Robux) | |
| Therapy Dog | Uncommon | Great Ormond Charity Update | |
| Tree Kangaroo | Legendary | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Unicorn | Legendary | Retired Egg | |
| White Amazon | Legendary | Golden Plantain | |
| Winged Horse | Legendary | Robux | |
| Zebra | Rare | Regular Egg |
